Should I Learn Piano or Guitar
Should I Learn Piano or Guitar is a common question for beginner students who are tossing up between learning the two instruments.
They are both beautiful sounding and extremely versatile
In an ideal world you’d be able to learn both piano and guitar simultaneously
However this isn’t always possible for a wide range of reasons such as time, location, cost etc.
If you are genuinely torn between piano and guitar I’ve listed a few past student questions that may help you decide
**In this article the terms Piano and Keyboard are interchangeable**
***It’s always my recommendation to learn the instrument you think you’ll love the most and to not overthink things***
Should I Learn Piano or Guitar Student Questions
Piano or Guitar, which is easiest to learn?
Firstly I’d like to state the degree of difficulty for both instruments is equal
However due to the physiological requirements and logical structure of notes, the piano will be easier than guitar to learn in the first instance
This is because in order to produce a sound on guitar you need some precision.
You’ll need apply pressure to a string and apply it to a correct position on the fret otherwise you’ll produce a dead or buzzing sound
With piano you only need to touch a key to produce a sound with the slightest pressure and you don’t need to worry about the positioning of your finger
The notes on the guitar fretboard will seem all over the place
While the notes on the piano are symmetrical making them easier to find unlike the guitar
Based on this the piano will be easier than the guitar to learn in the short term
However it won’t be long before you encounter more complexities and coordination requirements
Can I play all songs and styles with Piano or Guitar?
Essentially you can play most styles of music and songs on the guitar and piano equally such as Jazz, contemporary, rock etc.
Most songs are transcribed for both instruments
The notes and chords on the treble clef are interchangeable between the two
However there are some exceptions or differences
Percussive styles are better suited to the guitar such as Flamenco
The Guitar is restricted to only playing notes in the treble meaning you won’t be able to play bass notes
The piano has both a bass and treble clef giving it a greater range than guitar
Having the bass clef on the piano means you can essentially play two instruments (Bass and Treble) at the same time
In a nutshell, yes you can play, compose, and arrange similar music on both instruments
Which instrument is more portable Piano or Guitar?
You’d think this answer is obviously the guitar
However with keyboards getting smaller with built in speakers and battery powered you can now take them anywhere
The advantage of guitar is that it can be used acoustically without the reliance of speakers, power and are light to carry
I know people who move acoustic pianos to various locations but trust me it ain’t easy
Can I compose songs with either Piano or Guitar?
You can compose songs on either piano or guitar
However you could argue that you’d get a fuller picture with piano as it also incorporates bass notes
Which one Piano or Guitar costs more in the long run?
Both instruments can really add up especially as you start to buy additional guitar accessories such as amplifiers, pedals and so forth
But generally speaking, beginner pianos or keyboards are generally more expensive than beginner guitars
However if you decide to learn electric guitar then the cost of guitar + amplifier will be about equal for a beginner piano instrument
As you progress and buy better instruments the cost increases for both
However ultimately piano will be more expensive with concert grade grand pianos going into the hundreds of thousands of dollars
Is the Piano or Guitar best for singing?
Good singers should be able to sing with either instrument
However you’ll find that most beginner to intermediate singers who have taken lessons are more comfortable with the piano
This is due to singing teachers generally using pianos to assist singers with pitch and often accompanying them with piano.
Piano also gives you the opportunity to play melody and chords simultaneously making it easier to follow a tune
A lot of singers struggle to pick the melody when only chords are played on the guitar unless they are used to it or have a good understanding of music theory or a really good ear
Therefore if you plan to play and sing at the same time or play for other singers then the piano might be a bit easier to start with than the guitar
If you know what you’re doing you’ll be able to easily use both. That’s a plug to get lessons 🙂
It’s always your best to go with the instrument you think will give you the most pleasure. This will ensure you stay motivated and will equal success
Hopefully some of these questions mentioned will help you make a better decision on whether to learn piano or guitar
If you’d like to get more information or to organise either piano or guitar lessons you can get in touch with me via my contact page
All the best with your studies and if you have any more questions or feedback please leave them in the comments section below